top | item 45635246

(no title)

warent | 4 months ago

Equating “business” to “profound human intimacy” might be one of the most HackerNews comments of all time

discuss

order

igor47|4 months ago

Jobs aren't just business. Humans derive a lot of meaning from being useful and valued.

swat535|4 months ago

> Jobs aren't just business. Humans derive a lot of meaning from being useful and valued.

No one is feeling useful or valued working a double shift at Walmart in order to put food on the table.

Feeling useful and valued can come from other means such as caring for the elderly and doing volunteer work.

Majority of people work to simply survive because without it, they would end up homeless and hungry.

eli_gottlieb|4 months ago

For most people, most of the time, jobs are a lot closer to "just business" than "marital intimacy".

warent|4 months ago

You’re right and validating the point.

A specific part of GP’s comment keeps getting overlooked:

  So the problem isn't robots, it's the structure of how we humans rely on jobs for income.
Humans being forced to trade time for survival, money, and the enrichment of the elite, is a bug. We are socially conditioned to believe it’s a feature and the purpose.

Nobody is saying robots should replace human connection and expression

Edit: tone

melagonster|4 months ago

People cannot find new jobs so quickly. They will starve and probably die. This is more like the right of having life.

beeflet|4 months ago

I think you overstate the profundity. And like business it is a market and much of the same rules apply.

If you disagree, feel free to argue your point instead of just scoffing at the idea.

mmaunder|4 months ago

Sex, garbage collection, it’s all the same on HN.

SkyeCA|4 months ago

My job is more important than intimacy. Intimacy won't keep me warm, or fed.

dmd|4 months ago

If intimacy doesn’t keep you warm you might be doing something wrong.