top | item 45674870

(no title)

mh9r | 4 months ago

I tried Jujutsu in the last day and was going through your tutorial. I really liked the experience and can see some potential. I also got the feeling that there is a missing puzzle piece. For example, do I get any benefit from the change id if I push to GitHub for PR review?

I guess you benefit from some of the good parts only with the Google internal Piper backend, at the moment. So I’m curious about the ideas and plans you have at ERSC.

But what I’m also really yearning for is having a distributed asynchronous/offline-first code review flow built right in. The distributed nature of git somehow got lost with PRs or MRs in GitHub & Co.

discuss

steveklabnik|4 months ago

Glad to hear you enjoyed it :)

> do I get any benefit from the change id if I push to GitHub for PR review?

As of right now? Not really. The details are more complicated, but basically, if your project doesn't like the behavior of github when it comes to comments + editing commits, and wants you to tack on new commits instead, we can't change that behavior. However, https://github.com/LucioFranco/jj-spr can, in some situations, give you some of this experience. If your project is okay with editing commits, then it can help you locally, sure.

However. In an interesting turn of developments, GitHub's new SVP just tweeted that he's likes jj and is interested in adding stacked diffs to github. I don't know how this squares with their "no new features for 18 months" thing, but we'll see!

> But what I’m also really yearning for is having a distributed asynchronous/offline-first code review flow built right in.

It's not code review, it's issue tracking, but I've been using https://github.com/steveyegge/beads this week, and I think it might be the first "put your issues in your repo" system I actually enjoy. It says it's built for AI stuff, but like, you don't have to use AI with it.

CGamesPlay|4 months ago

One thing to note is that the actual commit objects you make through jj do include a `change-id` header which means that even though Github is unaware of jj, peers using jj will still be able to keep track of the rebases.

Demo: run `git cat-file -p HEAD` in any jj repository that you've made a change to.