[maxdamantus]

I think the model I described is more precise than madvise. I think madvise would usually be called on large sequences of pages, which is why it has `MADV_RANDOM`, `MADV_SEQUENTIAL` etc. You're not specifying which memory/pages are about to be accessed, but the likely access pattern.

If you're just using mmap to read a file from start to finish, then the `hint_read` mechanism is indeed pointless, since multiple `hint_read` calls would do the same thing as a single `madvise(..., MADV_SEQUENTIAL)` call.

The point of `hint_read`, and indeed io_uring or `readv` is the program knows exactly what parts of the file it wants to read first, so it would be best if those are read concurrently, and preferably using a single system call or page fault (ie, one switch to kernel space).

I would expect the `hint_read` function to push to a queue in thread-local storage, so it shouldn't need a switch to kernel space. User/kernel space switches are slow, in the order of a couple of 10s of millions per second. This is why the vDSO exists, and why the libc buffers writes through `fwrite`/`println`/etc, because function calls within userspace can happen at rates of billions per second.

[gpderetta]

you can do fine grained madvise via io_uring, which indeed uses a queue. But at that point why use mmap at all, just do async reads via io_uring.

[vlovich123]

The entire point I was trying to make at the beginning of the thread is that mmap gives you memory pages in the page cache that the OS can drop on memory pressure. Io_uring is close on the performance and fine-grained access patterns front. It’s not so good on the system-wide cooperative behavior with memory front and has a higher cost as either you’re still copying it from the page cache into a user buffer (non trivial performance impact vs the read itself) + trashing your CPU caches or you’re doing direct I/O and having to implement a page cache manually (and risks duplicating page data inefficiently in userspace if the same file is accessed by multiple processes.