[xfalcox]

Also worth mentioning that we use quantization extensively:

- halfvec (16bit float) for storage - bit (binary vectors) for indexes

Which makes the storage cost and on-going performance good enough that we could enable this in all our hosting.

[simonw]

It still amazes me that the binary trick works.

For anyone who hasn't seen it yet: it turns out many embedding vectors of e.g. 1024 floating point numbers can be reduced to a single bit per value that records if it's higher or lower than 0... and in this reduced form much of the embedding math still works!

This means you can e.g. filter to the top 100 using extremely memory efficient and fast bit vectors, then run a more expensive distance calculation against those top 100 with the full floating point vectors to pick the top 10.

[xfalcox]

I was taken back when I saw what was basically zero recall loss in the real world task of finding related topics, by doing the same thing you described where we over capture with binary embeddings, and only use the full (or half) precision on the subset.

Making the storage cost of the index 32 times smaller is the difference of being able to offer this at scale without worrying too much about the overhead.

[tveita]

Depending on your data you might also get better results by applying a random rotation to your vector before quantization.

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/6296665/ (https://refbase.cvc.uab.cat/files/GLG2012b.pdf)

[FuckButtons]

why is this amazing, it’s just a 1 bit lossy compression representation of the original information? If you have a vector in n-dimensional space this is effectively just representing the basis vectors that the original has.

[3abiton]

Now that you mention that, I wonder if LSH would perform better with slightly higher memory footprint

[summarity]

That's where it's at. I'm using the 1600D vectors from OpenAI models for findsight.ai, stored SuperBit-quantized. Even without fancy indexing, a full scan (1 search vector -> 5M stored vectors), takes less than 40ms. And with basic binning, it's nearly instant.

[tacoooooooo]

this is at the expense of precision/recall though isn't it?

[mfrye0]

I was going to say the same. We're using binary vectors in prod as well. Makes a huge difference in the indexes. This wasn't mentioned once in the article.