top | item 45808867

(no title)

lccerina | 3 months ago

"not designed by humans"? Since when? Unless you count cortical organoids /wetware (grown in some instrumented petri dish) every artificial neural network, doesn't matter how complicated, it is designed by humans. With equations and rules designed by humans. Backpropagation, optimization algorithms, genetic selections etc... all designed by humans.

There is no biology here, and there are so many other words that describe perfectly what they are doing here, without twisting the meaning of another word.

discuss

order

UltraSane|3 months ago

By not designed I'm talking about the synaptic weights

lccerina|3 months ago

Still designed by humans. The loss function, backpropagation and all other mechanisms didn't just appear magically in the neural network. Someone decided which loss function to use, which architecture or which optimization techniques. Only because it takes a big GPU a lot of number crunching to assign those weights, it doesn't mean it's biological.

In the same way, a weather forecast model using a lot of complicated differential equations is not biological. A finite element model analyzing some complicated electromagnetic field, or the aerodynamics of a car is not biological. Just because someone around 70-75 years ago called them 'perceptrons' or 'neurons' instead of thingamajigs does not make them biology.