top | item 45827906

(no title)

Munksgaard | 3 months ago

Also, while not exactly the algorithm Raph is looking for, here is a bracket matching function (from Pareas, which he also mentions in the talk) in Futhark: https://github.com/Snektron/pareas/blob/master/src/compiler/...

I haven't studied it in depth, but it's pretty readable.

discuss

order

pythomancer|3 months ago

(author here) check_brackets_bt is actually exactly the algorithm that Raph mentions

raphlinus|3 months ago

Right. This is the binary tree version of the algorithm, and is nice and concise, very readable. What would take it to the next level for me is the version in the stack monoid paper, which chunks things up into workgroups. I haven't done benchmarks against the Pareas version (unfortunately it's not that easy), but I would expect the workgroup optimized version to be quite a bit faster.

Munksgaard|3 months ago

Thanks for clarifying! It would indeed be interesting to see a comparison between similar implementations in other languages, both in terms of readability and performance. I feel like the readability can hardly get much better than what you wrote, but I don't know!