top | item 45837524

(no title)

TrueDuality | 3 months ago

This is a false equivalency I'm surprised no one else has brought up. An archive of a site preserves attribution inherently, the scraping and training are not.

discuss

order

kulahan|3 months ago

Is it? I thought it was ridiculous at first, but the more I think of it... both are scenarios where a corporation is scraping billions of webpages. We like the reason archive.is does it, but unless it's some kind of charity, I think it's a reasonable comparison.

didibus|3 months ago

archive.is is a charity no? Or at least they take donations, it seems the legal entity behind it is nebulous, but they don't have ads and have no paid product or offering.

warkdarrior|3 months ago

So if OpenAI or <AI scraper of the day> adds attribution to their AI-generated answers, everything is OK?

cestith|3 months ago

It would be closer to okay.