top | item 45851850

(no title)

vlucas | 3 months ago

You can't, and this was readily apparent in 2020 with Covid. Even doctors presenting factual information got censored and de-platformed by YouTube.

The only real competing video platform that promises no censorship is Rumble ( https://rumble.com ), but it has a very right-wing slant due to conservatives flocking to it during all the Covid-era social media censorship.

discuss

order

chasd00|3 months ago

Yeah the moment they started I knew it was doomed to fail. Get it wrong once and your credibility is ruined. They should have never tried to censor content outside of what is legally required and therefore defined.

aucisson_masque|3 months ago

I kind of agree but laws vary from countries to countries. It's quite an hassle to know what is legal in one country and not in another.

Take freedom of speech for instance, half the thing you can say in usa would be deemed as hate speech in Europe.

immibis|3 months ago

Society is doomed because we stopped silencing disinformation peddlers. We know what happens when Nazis are allowed to spread propaganda freely - because that happened one time in Germany, and we saw the results. We don't know what happens when antivaxxers are allowed to spread propaganda freely, but it's not hard to guess, and measles cases are on the rise. You can argue it's not YouTube's problem to solve, but nobody else is solving it, so it's hard for me to blame them for trying.

There's also this annoying pattern where 98% of the complaints about censorship are from people who are mad that the objectively stupid and dangerous stuff they were trying to profit from got censored, so it becomes a "boy who cried wolf" situation where any complaint about internet censorship is ignored on the assumption it's one of those. (What if there really is a Nigerian prince who needs my help, and I don't read his email?)

This time, though... Society is not being destroyed by people pirating Windows 11. That is entirely different from censoring things that destroy society, and they don't have a good excuse.

zahlman|3 months ago

> promises no censorship... has a very right-wing slant

https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/01/neutral-vs-conservativ...

> The moral of the story is: if you’re against witch-hunts, and you promise to found your own little utopian community where witch-hunts will never happen, your new society will end up consisting of approximately three principled civil libertarians and seven zillion witches. It will be a terrible place to live even if witch-hunts are genuinely wrong.

MYEUHD|3 months ago

If you want to avoid censorship, self-host Peertube and have peave of mind.

davidmurdoch|3 months ago

That's just self censorship, since no one will see your videos there

autoexec|3 months ago

I looked at the front page alone and it's full of right wing hot takes and neo-nazis. If a platform wants to accept white-supremacists that's one thing. When it's right on their front page though it's being actively promoted.

Rumble isn't going to save the internet.

myko|3 months ago

Right, it is explicitly a neo-Nazi platform

stOneskull|3 months ago

odysee is similar but maybe with more of an anarchist/conspiracy theory slant than rumble