top | item 45880345

(no title)

QuantumFunnel | 3 months ago

"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety."

discuss

order

GuinansEyebrows|3 months ago

i will never tire of the irony of a man who owned humans being lauded as a freedom fighter.

CamperBob2|3 months ago

Whatever you're doing at the moment, I'll bet somebody 200 years from now will condemn it.

It might not even take that long, at the rate we're progressing.

estearum|3 months ago

And yet every society makes exactly this trade off.

There is no such thing as avoiding this trade off entirely.

dwattttt|3 months ago

"Those (the Penn family) who would give up essential Liberty (money & power), to purchase a little temporary Safety (a veto over a taxation dispute, trying to raise money from the Penn family), deserve neither Liberty (said money & power) nor Safety (the defense that said taxed money would've bought from the present French & Indian wars)"

zahlman|3 months ago

The context of the original quote doesn't prevent others from finding it more generally applicable or well-put.

Terr_|3 months ago

> Those (the Penn family) who would give up essential Liberty

No, you've got it half-backwards.

He's saying the democratic legislature shouldn't forever give up the citizens' collective Liberty to tax the ultra-mega-rich (Penns) in exchange for a one-time Security payment from those rich near-nobles.

https://www.npr.org/2015/03/02/390245038/ben-franklins-famou...