top | item 45910950

Hacker News rewrites post without consent?

3 points| rrwright | 3 months ago |news.ycombinator.com

8 comments

order

rrwright|3 months ago

I posted a link to an important Claude Code bug here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45910257 with the original title of "Claude Code Introduces Off-by-One Errors"

It made it to the front page at about #11. Then apparently the editors renamed it to the (less interesting/more convoluted) title of the page it linked to. I didn't cause or approve that change. Why does HN rewrite my post? Is it because it was negative to Claude Code?

Original: https://pasteboard.co/xTjaRmnkhRRo.png

HN edited it to: https://pasteboard.co/rDPINchmufIF.png

AlbertoGP|3 months ago

> Then apparently the editors renamed it to the (less interesting/more convoluted) title of the page it linked to.

It is part of the submission guidelines:

> Otherwise please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

chasing0entropy|3 months ago

HN is not a social media site. Upvotes for your creative title on an interesting article is not the goal; sharing the interesting article is. Please stop trying to migrate your social media vanity score to one of the last legit forums on the net.

muwtyhg|3 months ago

Surely the fact that there is a comment section on user submitted media means this website is social media?

DecentShoes|3 months ago

Yes it does and it's super shitty, yet they still continue to show it as if it was submitted by the original poster. I agree this isn't okay.