[unleashit]

Side question: It looks interesting but what's with the trend of open source projects providing such bloated installs? The recommended getting started with docker (which first recommends cloning a 350mb repo) seems to assume you need to scale to 100s+ users. At a glance, in their default docker compose I counted no less than 12 containers including nginx, redis and minio. I can't imagine any of these are necessary to run an app on a single localhost machine.

I understand they're trying to attract enterprisy customers, but even some of those are probably going to want to try it out first. Would be nice to have an easy minimal install option that doesn't require a deep dive into the project to figure out.

[Weves]

Have you checked out https://docs.onyx.app/deployment/getting_started/quickstart#...?

We should definitely update the Local guide to reflect the ^, thanks for pointing that out.

For the container footprint - pretty much all of them are necessary to run locally. We hope that just a large # of containers shouldn't be a problem, as long as they are all lightweight (e.g. total resource utilization is low). We of course could bundle them together into a single "mega container", but that seems against the best practices of Docker.

On a related note, we are looking to have a version that doesn't require the vector database (the heaviest part of the system in terms of resource utilization). Our goal is to have a deployment mode with less than 1gb of RAM required.

[unleashit]

Hey, the bottom line is the project looks promising and I'm sure it's a lot of hard work. That said, because time is limited, for now I'll have to pass on spinning it up for the reasons mentioned. I took a look at the shell script, and it just seems like a helpful wrapper (with cleanup) over a manual install. I didn't mean to say it's about the amount of containers. All of those services take up a lot of resources, especially compared to the alternatives.

For example, Openwebui can be run with just a sqlite database and a backend. Why is nginx needed, or Minio on a single machine with a nice local file system? But I also understand it takes more work to support multiple service configurations so please accept the criticism as constructive (and it's more a general observation of what I've noticed over the past few years).