[shuckles]

You've just listed a set of specific circumstances under which some number of people might find housing more affordable, but that's a lot more like "investment outperformance" driven affordability than "broad based housing price decrease" affordability. That can happen even without a recession. A small number of people could've found Bay Area houses more affordable in the last decade if they were HODLing some 10x stock.

[harmmonica]

FWIW I think I just listed a set of circumstances that happen every time there is a drop in housing prices historically, at least going back to the 90's savings and loan crisis. I'll tell you when people found Bay Area houses more affordable? 2009-2012. And during that time the unemployment rate was at roughly 10 or 12% (had to look it up just now but knew it was around there). Housing prices during that same time? Dropped as low as 40-50% in some parts of the Bay (best case they were down 20%+). 10x stock needed? No. A job? Yes. You can repeat the exercise for the start of Covid, but the timeline for the drop in prices, and the % drop, was muted in comparison to the housing crisis. Same for S&L crisis. Dotcom bust too, though, again, housing prices didn't crater like the housing crisis.