top | item 46185473

(no title)

FanaHOVA | 2 months ago

Are you saying that every piece of code you have ever written contains a full source list of every piece of code you previously read to learn specific languages, patterns, etc?

Or are you saying that every piece of code you ever wrote was 100% original and not adapted from any previous codebase you ever worked in or any book / reference you ever read?

discuss

order

pests|2 months ago

While I generally agree with you, this "LLM is a human" comparisons really are tiresome I feel. It hasn't been proven and I don't know how many other legal issued could have solved if adding "like a human" made it okay. Google v Oracle? "oh, you've never learned an API??!?" or take the original Google Books controversy - "its reading books and memorizing them, like humans can". I do agree its different but I don't like this line of argument at all.

FanaHOVA|2 months ago

I agree, that's why I was trying to point out that saying "if a person did that we'd have a word for them" is useless. They are not people, and people don't behave like that anyway. It adds nothing to the discussion.

jacquesm|2 months ago

What's with the bad takes in this thread. That's two strawmen in one comment, it's getting a bit crowded.

DangitBobby|2 months ago

Or the original point doesn't actually hold up to basic scrutiny and is indistinguishable from straw itself.