top | item 46219671

(no title)

MLgulabio | 2 months ago

This doesn't change my argument at all.

The more money you have, more you benefit from this ruling. Now you can buy a service which was not possible before.

discuss

order

stetrain|2 months ago

The rich were driving before, and are still driving.

The difference is that now they are paying for that service they were already using, and those funds are going to public transit which serves the majority of New Yorkers especially those with lower incomes.

CryptoBanker|2 months ago

The problem is that no one in NYC, rich or poor, has any confidence in the MTA's ability to properly and efficiently use these funds. This stems from a long history of incompetence and wastefulness by the MTA

SoftTalker|2 months ago

Are the funds actually going to public transit, or are they being used to pay off all the people whose support was needed to implement the congestion charges?

ceejayoz|2 months ago

> Now you can buy a service which was not possible before.

It wasn't possible to drive a car in NYC before congestion pricing? I find that… unlikely.

MLgulabio|2 months ago

It wasn't possible to buy reduced traffic.

JumpCrisscross|2 months ago

> more money you have, more you benefit from this ruling

This is nonsense.

The poor of New York benefit from congestion pricing. It means more funding for the public transit they predominantly take. And for the minority who drive for a living it increases their revenues.

The opposition to congestion charges comes from principally outside New York, often from folks who have little to no familiarity with it.

MLgulabio|2 months ago

As long as this system is a fixed price and is independent of the salary you earn, its benefits the rich more.

Its the same principle with kindergarden and late fee; Without a late fee, people sometimes were late getting their kids, with late fees more people were late getting their kids. Now they were able to 'pay' for this.

You now can pay for having less traffic for you. Who can afford this? The rich/richer person.

This increases inequality.