[SomaticPirate]

Seeing a ton of adoption of this after the Minio debacle

https://www.repoflow.io/blog/benchmarking-self-hosted-s3-com... was useful.

RustFS also looks interesting but for entirely non-technical reasons we had to exclude it.

Anyone have any advice for swapping this in for Minio?

[dpedu]

I have not tried either myself, but I wanted to mention that Versity S3 Gateway looks good too.

https://github.com/versity/versitygw

I am also curious how Ceph S3 gateway compares to all of these.

[skrtskrt]

When I was there, DigitalOcean was writing a complete replacement for the Ceph S3 gateway because its performance under high concurrency was awful.

They just completely swapped out the whole service from the stack and wrote one in Go because of how much better the concurrency management was, and Ceph's team and codebase C++ was too resistant to change.

[zipzad]

I'd be curious to know how versitygw compares to rclone serve S3.

[chrislusf]

Disclaim: I work on SeaweedFS.

Why skipping SeaweedFS? It rank #1 on all benchmarks, and has a lot of features.

[meotimdihia]

I confirm this, I used SeaweedFS to serve 1M users daily with 56 million images / ~100TB with 2 servers + HDD only, while Minio can't do this. Seaweedfs performance is much better than Minio's. The only problem is that SeaweedFS documentation is hard to understand.

[ted_dunning]

SeaweedFS is very nice and takes quite an effort to lose data.

[dionian]

can you link benchmarks

[Implicated]

> but for entirely non-technical reasons we had to exclude it

Able/willing to expand on this at all? Just curious.

[misnome]

They seem to have gone all-in on AI, for commits and ticket management. Not interested in interacting with that.

Otherwise, the built in admin on one-executable was nice, and support for tiered storage, but single node parallel write performance was pretty unimpressive and started throwing strange errors (investigating of which led to the AI ticket discovery).

[NitpickLawyer]

Not the same person you asked, but my guess would be that it is seen as a chinese product.

[elvinagy]

I’m Elvin from the RustFS team in the U.S. Thanks for sharing the benchmark; it’s helpful to see how RustFS performs in real-world setups.

We know trust matters, especially for a newer project, and we try to earn it through transparency and external validation. we were excited to see RustFS recently added as an optional service in Laravel Sail’s official Docker environment (PR #822). Having our implementation reviewed and accepted by a major ecosystem like Laravel was an encouraging milestone for us.

If the “non-technical reasons” you mentioned are around licensing or governance, I’m happy to discuss our long-term Apache 2.0 commitment and path to a stable GA.

[scottydelta]

From what I have seen in the previous discussions here (since and before Minio debacle) and at work, Garage is a solid replacement.

[klooney]

Seaweed looks good in those benchmarks, I haven't heard much about it for a while.