top | item 46528269

(no title)

j_w | 1 month ago

There are bad questions (and ideas, like you said). Stackoverflow tried to incentivize asking good, novel questions. You grow up often being told "there are no stupid questions" but that is absolutely not the case.

A good question isn't just "how do I do x in y language?" But something more like "I'm trying to do x in y language. Here's what I've tried: <code> and here is the issue I have <output or description of issue>. <More details as relevant>"

This does two things: 1. It demonstrates that the question ask-er actually cares about whatever it is they are doing, and it's just trying to get free homework answers. 2. Ideally it forces the ask-er to provide enough information that an answer-er can do so without asking follow ups.

discuss

order

stackskipton|1 month ago

I'm reminded of this link: http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html

Biggest thing as someone who has been in Discords that are geared towards support, you can either gear towards new people or professionals but walking the line between both is almost impossible.

zahlman|1 month ago

I believe in gearing towards teachers. Q&A sites are often at their best when the Q and A come from the same source. But it needs to be someone who understands that the Q is common and can speak the language of those who don't know the A. Unfortunately, not a common skillset (typically doesn't pay the bills).

zahlman|1 month ago

> You grow up often being told "there are no stupid questions" but that is absolutely not the case.

There are no stupid questions, but there are stupid choices about whom to ask.

Often the right choice is yourself.