[daheza]

If we all ditch our phones then how will we record the abuses of power?

[ActorNightly]

Hate to break it to you, but people just simply dont care as much as you think they do. We have the right to own firearms for the purposes of protecting us against tyrany, but thats pointless when we cant even realize tyrany right outside our door.

[noncoml]

This shows how flawed the idea is that individual gun ownership protects people from a rogue government. Acting alone with a firearm does not stop tyranny. It only leads to prison or worse.

Real resistance to authoritarianism has never come from isolated individuals using violence. It requires organized collective action where people stand together and refuse to comply. History shows that meaningful resistance often begins with simple nonviolent acts like refusing unjust rules or asserting basic dignity rather than a lone person reaching for a gun.

Owning a gun by itself does not meaningfully protect anyone from government overreach. Organization solidarity and collective action do.

[beej71]

I have an old point and shoot (20x optical zoom) and a SIM-free phone that has never been used in my name for anything.

[tonyarkles]

> SIM-free phone

Is the modem completely disabled? Does it still show the "SOS" option that allows you to call 911 without a SIM? If so, and if it's ever been turned on in your residence, there's a decent chance the IMEI could be traced back to your house just based on pattern-of-life movement.

[steele]

Analog recording and viewing may need to become the state of the art given how low the bar has become to manipulate digital media

[pavel_lishin]

Burners, which you never bring anywhere near your home, and which you do not drive your car to pick up.

[lapetitejort]

Point and clicks with no internet connectivity. Practice unloading and reloading SD cards in came someone comes to destroy evidence

[dredmorbius]

There are inexpensive dedicated still and video cameras, for as little as $40.

Higher-quality devices will still cost markedly less than a flagship, or even several-years-old smartphone, and will have much greater lifespan absent misadventure.

[kazinator]

- Use a different device: tablet, or camera.

- Do bring your phone, but put it into "airplane mode" so that it doesn't talk to any cell towers; then upload the video somewhere as soon as you get out of the area

[gruez]

Phone on airplane mode and with location services disabled?

[therobots927]

I doubt that would do anything…

[codingdave]

Buy a camera. And/or an audio recorder. Or pull the SIM out of an old phone and use that.

[pengaru]

I wouldn't assume pulling a SIM is enough to hide the phone's location. The modem will still be powered, the IMEI isn't part of the SIM card and is a unique identifier. Plus last I checked you can still contact 911 without being a subscriber.

I'm no expert on cell networks but my impression is the baseband will still ping towers and participate in the cell network on some level. If the phone gets confiscated or its IMEI otherwise associated with you, it can probably be abused to try place you in an area at a given time even without the SIM card.

Just use cameras without any RF hardware. (they tend to have better optics / zoom capabilities anyways)

[jacquesm]

A phone with its SIM out is still registering with the network.

[fsflover]

Librem 5 phone has a hardware kill switch for the modem. The camera is not so great though.

[pklausler]

Disposable film cameras and FRS walkie-talkies, I think.

[dredmorbius]

FRS: family radio service, a broadcast communications technology, TIL:

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Radio_Service>

[layer8]

There are standalone pocket cameras.

[everdrive]

People have allowed themselves to become so dependent on mobile phones that I'm frankly disgusted. You're talking about a scenario where you're worried about being illegally arrested by the secret police -- aided by their tracking of your phone, but it's still not enough to consider using your phone less. It's no different that a rat starving to death but continuing to push the lever for the cocaine hit.

[edit]

Vote me down all you want. If a bulletin went out that said "we're going to use your phone to steal your children and torture them" you'd have people saying "but, but .. how am I going to do my banking and check my messages." It's the height of absurdity.

[chasd00]

yeah it's kind of amazing, just leave your phone at home and the tracking problem is solved (if one even really exists to begin with). If you want to document something bring a simple digital camera. They pretty much all have video and audio capability too. Like how is this not obvious to everyone?

edit: just want to point out there are still cameras everywhere so if you're worried about being found just leaving your phone at home isn't going to do much

[8note]

id just bring my phone. if the secret police are going to arrest or kill me, theyre going to do it either way, probably while im there.

if i bring a phone, i can at least document the secret police's actions, and make friends and get contact info for other people that are there.

security by obfuscation isnt particularly good, and its a state level threat.

there's a different absurdity with your child torture example - that youd be ok with children being tortured over phone usage. the bulletin and the people doing the kidnapping at torture are the problem, not the phone. there's a third option of stopping said torturers, and youll likely want your phone as one of the tools in doing so

[chaps]

....cameras exist :)

[daheza]

True, cameras can be taken away or smashed after the fact destroying evidence.

With my phone I can stream video to a cloud so that it can't be deleted. The ACLU used to have an app specifically for this but it seems to have been discontinued. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACLU_Mobile_Justice