top | item 46559191

(no title)

petiepooo | 1 month ago

People still use UPnP? That's the first thing I disable on a new router.

discuss

order

jeroenhd|1 month ago

I use UPnP. My Fritz!Box router disables it by default, controls UPnP access with per-device controls, and permits using it to open IPv6 ports on the WAN side as well.

None of the IoT crap can open ports but I don't need to use a web UI to temporarily open a port on my computer.

I know plenty of shitty routers have terrible security on it and should have it disabled by default, but the protocol itself is pretty useful.

drnick1|1 month ago

Aren't those Fritz!Box routers (common in Europe) precisely examples of "shitty routers with terrible security?"

The first thing I would do with a typical residential Internet connection is to ask the ISP to give me an ONT so that I can use my own router, a commodity x86 PC running Linux. Their underpowered plastic boxes simply won't cut it when it comes to complex firewall rules and high VPN throughput. I also don't want to deal with their shitty web UIs and would rather script the setup I want.

miladyincontrol|1 month ago

I do not use UPnP myself but I agree with the notion, hate the bad implementations not the protocol itself. When limited to specific ports by specific devices it does have its uses.

imcritic|1 month ago

Isn't fritz a derogatory term for Germans? That's a weird choice of a name for a router. Or is it like a joke? Or maybe Germans aren't familiar with that slur?

jcelerier|1 month ago

what are the other options, if I want to open a port and don't want (or can't) to go to the router config ?

kelnos|1 month ago

If you have the ability to disable UPnP on the router, then you presumably have the ability to set up port forwards manually. "Don't want" doesn't come into play; if you disable UPnP, that's the trade off you're making.