[somebehemoth]

There is no criticism. He did not read the paper.

[rpdillon]

I read the entire paper, and his criticism is spot on. I even read through many of the references, which, in my spot checks, don't support the claims in the paper. Very disappointing work, IMHO.

[somebehemoth]

Cool. Perhaps you should have criticized the paper and requested feedback instead of defending someone who did not read the paper!