[aghilmort]

yeah, one way to frame is have to have structural parity & semantic parity & bridge to & from both like balanced scales.

We started with structure to help others solve semantics. Your approach doing same thing from other direction!

While theoretically possible to do just one or other in nested way it’s much easier to do little bit of both, especially if want anything approaching associative recall & reasoning. Akin to dynamically balancing volume between parts of songs or reprojecting continuously into some frequency envelope etc.

[elevenapril]

I'm going to steal that "dynamically balancing volume" metaphor.

It perfectly explains why static rules usually aren't enough on their own. We need that runtime "remixing" to get a clear signal.

Thanks for the deep dive. It’s rare to find this kind of nuanced discussion in a Show HN thread!

[aghilmort]

yep! think dynamic amplifier / equalizer

inflight token tuning of signal boost, SNR, etc.

& for sure / likewise!