[aeonik]

I am not even sure what this means, but it seems backwards to me.

    "If not by sheer luck, all valid evidence, old and new, related to the one and only location of MH370, can only be reconciled IF that location is known in advance."

Author could be right about the hypothesis, but I'd want to see more evidence that this location had significance to the pilot.

Some of the criticism is accurate, but the paper needs more evidence overall as well.