[quuxplusone]

Our points of view are probably not too far off, really. Remember this whole thought-experiment is counterfactual: we're imagining what "automatic extraction of function declarations from a .c file" would have looked like in the K&R era, in response to claims (from 50 years later) that "No sane programming language should require a duplication in order to export something" and "The .h could have been a compiler output." So we're both having to imagine the motivations and design requirements of a hypothetical programmer from the 1970s or 1980s.

I agree that the tool I sketched wouldn't let your .h file contain macros, nor C99 inline functions, nor is it clear how it would distinguish between structs whose definition must be "exported" (like sockaddr_t) and structs where a declaration suffices (like FILE). But:

- Does our hypothetical programmer care about those limitations? Maybe he doesn't write libraries that depend on exporting macros. He (counterfactually) wants this tool; maybe that indicates that his preferences and priorities are different from his contemporaries'.

- C++20 Modules also do not let you export macros. The "toy" tool we can build with 1970s technology happens to be the same in this respect as the C++20 tool we're emulating! A modern programmer might indeed say "That's not a useful software engineering tool, because macros" — but I presume they'd say the exact same thing about C++20 Modules. (And I wouldn't even disagree! I'm just saying that that particular objection does not distinguish this hypothetical 1970s .h-file-generator from the modern C++20 Modules facility.)

[EDIT: Or to put it better, maybe: Someone-not-you might say, "I love Modules! Why couldn't we have had it in the 1970s, by auto-generating .h files?" And my answer is, we could have. (Yes it couldn't have handled macros, but then neither can C++20 Modules.) So why didn't we get it in the 1970s? Not because it would have been physically difficult at all, but rather — I speculate — because for cultural reasons it wasn't wanted.]