top | item 46841937

(no title)

fred_is_fred | 29 days ago

We do the same here in the US for Mississippi, Arkansas, and other states and they only get worse - at least Poland has a path out here.

discuss

order

rayiner|29 days ago

We don’t have any similar program in the U.S. You seem to be talking about the fact that some states pay a larger share of the federal tax burden. That’s just a consequence of progressive taxation and those states having more rich people.

In terms of federal grants to states on a per-capita basis, Mississippi gets less than California, and a bit more than Massachusetts: https://ffis.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/SA24-02-1.pdf. Some of the states with very high grants relative to population are states that have a lot of natural resources and get federal lease payments and things like that.

Also, the gap between richer states and poorer states has closed dramatically. In 1950, the nominal per capita personal income in New York was 2.4 times higher than Mississippi. Today’s it’s about 60% higher. Adjusted for cost of living, incomes in New York today are only about 11% higher today: https://flowingdata.com/2021/03/25/income-in-each-state-adju...

0xy|28 days ago

Mississippi education standards are rapidly rising. They're 16th highest in the country after being 39th only 3 years ago.

Meanwhile, you've got NYC's new mayor vowing to destroy gifted programs, ensuring talented children are beaten down into average. Such attacks on gifted students are extremely common in the rich states.

KptMarchewa|29 days ago

The net per capita amount we get is dropping every year - mostly by the fact the contributions are rising fast.

scyzoryk_xyz|29 days ago

Might be worth adding that US comparisons aren't quite relevant. Poland is a relatively new member-country, not an existing state within a long standing union.

The Polish economy and success is simply the result of disciplined economic decisions and hard work. Apart from few political turbulences and ongoing constitutional crises we've managed to spend all the investment correctly. An enormous and matter-of-fact win-win.

Federal support for disadvantaged states is different (though really shouldn't be).