[nu11ptr]

Really? It seems better than ever to me now that we have gpui-component. That seems to finally open doors to have fully native guis that are polished enough for even commercial release. I haven't seen anything else that I would put in that category, but one choice is a start.

[piker]

The problem is that Zed has understandably and transparently abandoned supporting GPUI as an open source endeavour except to the extent contributions align with its business mission.

[nu11ptr]

I remember when that came out, but I'm not sure I understand the concern. They use GPUI, so therefore they MUST keep it working and supportable, even if updating it isn't their current priority. Or are you saying they have a closed source fork now?

Actually, this story is literally them changing their renderer on linux, so they are maintaining it.

> except to the extent contributions align with its business mission

Isn't that every single open source project that is tied to a commercial entity?

[iamnbutler]

They haven't. They are just heads down on other work. It wouldn't make sense for them to abandon it - they have no alternative. What that message was about was supporting _community_ prs and development of gpui.

Focus ebbs and flows at Zed, they'll be back on it before long.

[atombender]

I tried gpui recently and I found it to be very, very immature. Turns out even things like input components aren't in gpui, so if you want to display a dialog box with some text fields, you have to write it from scratch, including cursor, selection, clipboard etc. — Zed has all of that, but it's in their own internal crates.

Do you know how well gpui-component supports typical use cases like that? Edit boxes, buttons, scroll views, tables, checkbox/radio buttons, context menus, consistent native selection and clipboard support, etc. are table stakes for desktop apps.

[nu11ptr]

Yeah, running just gpui is kinda like writing a react app without a component library. It is going to be on you to implement all your components.

All of those are handled. Run the "story" app. It is very impressive IMO.

Components list: https://longbridge.github.io/gpui-component/docs/components/

[iamnbutler]

I do think gpui needs a native input element (enough that I wrote one (https://github.com/zed-industries/zed/pull/43576) just before they stopped reviewing gpui prs) but outside of that I think it is pretty ok and cool that gpui just exports the tools to make whatever components you need.

I could see more components being shipped first party if the community took over gpui, or for some crazy reason a team was funded to develop gpui full time, but developing baseline components is an immense amount of work, both to create an maintain.

Buttons (any div can be a button), clipboard, scroll views (div, list, uniform_list) should all already be in gpui.