[gunapologist99]

Garage installation is easy.

1. Download or build the single binary into your system (install like `/usr/local/sbin/garage`)

2. Create a file `/etc/garage.toml`:

  metadata_dir = "/data/garage/meta"
  data_dir = "/data/garage/data"
  db_engine = "sqlite"
  
  replication_factor = 1
  
  rpc_bind_addr = "[::]:3901"
  rpc_public_addr = "127.0.0.1:3901"
  rpc_secret = "[your rpc secret]"
  
  [s3_api]
  s3_region = "garage"
  api_bind_addr = "[::]:3900"
  root_domain = ".s3.garage.localhost"
  
  [s3_web]
  bind_addr = "[::]:3902"
  root_domain = ".web.garage.localhost"
  index = "index.html"
  
  [k2v_api]
  api_bind_addr = "[::]:3904"
  
  [admin]
  api_bind_addr = "[::]:3903"
  admin_token = "woG4Czw6957vNTXNfLABdCzI13NTP94M+qWENXUBThw="
  metrics_token = "3dRhgCRQQSxfplmYD+g1UTEZWT9qJBIsI56jDFy0VQU="

3. Start it with `garage server` or just have an AI write an init script or unit file for you. (You can pkill -f /usr/local/sbin/garage to shut it down.)

Also, NVIDIA has a phenomenal S3 compatible system that nobody seems to know about named AIStore: https://aistore.nvidia.com/ It's a bit more complex, but very powerful and fast (faster than MinIO - slightly less space efficient than MinIO because it maintains a complete copy of an object on a single node so that the object doesn't have to be reconstituted as it would on MinIO.) It also can be a proxy in front of other S3 systems, including AWS S3 or GCS etc and offer a single unified namespace to your clients.

IMO, Seaweedfs is still too much of a personal project, it's fast for small files, but keep good and frequent backups in a different system if you choose it.

I personally will avoid RustFS. Even if it was totally amazing, the Contributor License Agreement makes me feel like we're getting into the whole Minio rug-pull situation all over again, and you know what they say about doing the same thing and expecting a different result..

[pellepelster]

If you are on Hetzner, I created a ready to use Terraform module that spins up a single node GarageFs server https://pellepelster.github.io/solidblocks/hetzner/web-s3-do...

[zenoprax]

As someone about to learn the basics of Terraform, with an interest in geo-distributed storage, and with some Hetzner credit sitting idle... I came across the perfect comment this morning.

I might extend this with ZeroFS too.

[victormy]

Garage is indeed an excellent project, but I think it has a few drawbacks compared to the alternatives: Metadata Backend: It relies on SQLite. I have concerns about how well this scales or handles high concurrency with massive datasets. Admin UI: The console is still not very user-friendly/polished. Deployment Complexity: You are required to configure a "layout" (regions/zones) to get started, whereas MinIO doesn't force this concept on you for simple setups. Design Philosophy: While Garage is fantastic for edge/geo-distributed use cases, I feel its overall design still lags behind MinIO and RustFS. There is a higher barrier to entry because you have to learn specific Garage concepts just to get it running.

[Open-Sourcery]

It uses LMDB by default, but CAN use SQLite as an alternative [1]. LMDB is already used by OpenLDAP [2][3] and seems pretty bullet-proof.

[1] https://garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr/documentation/cookbook/real-w... [2] https://www.symas.com/mdb [3] https://www.openldap.org/

[__turbobrew__]

Regarding aistore the recommended prod configuration is kubernetes, which brings in a huge amount of complexity. Also, one person (Alex Aizman) has about half of the total commits in the project, so it seems like the bus factor is 1.

I could see running Aistore in single binary mode for small deployments, but for anything large and production grade I would not touch Aistore. Ceph is going to be the better option IMO, it is a truly collaborative open source project developed by multiple companies with a long track record.