top | item 47028548

(no title)

ramathornn | 14 days ago

Congrats to Peter!

Can any OpenClaw power users explain what value the software has provided to them over using Claude code with MCP?

I really don’t understand the value of an agent running 24/7, like is it out there working and earning a wage? Whats the real value here outside of buzzwords like an ai personal assistant that can do everything?

discuss

order

cactus2093|14 days ago

It has a heartbeat operation and you can message it via messaging apps.

Instead of going to your computer and launching claude code to have it do something, or setting up cron jobs to do things, you can message it from your phone whenever you have an idea and it can set some stuff up in the background or setup a scheduled report on its own, etc.

So it's not that it has to be running and generating tokens 24/7, it's just idling 24/7 any time you want to ping it.

deadbabe|14 days ago

Like what exactly? Can you give example of the type of prompts you are sending for the agent to do?

The messaging part isn’t particularly interesting. I can already access my local LLMs running on my Mac mini from anywhere.

catmanjan|14 days ago

AI companies must hate this right? Because they're selling tokens at a loss?

phamilton|14 days ago

As an experiment, I set it up with a z.ai $3/month subscription and told it to do a tedious technical task. I said to stay busy and that I expect no more than 30 minutes of inactivity, ever.

The task is to decompile Wave Race 64 and integrate with libultraship and eventually produce a runnable native port of the game. (Same approach as the Zelda OoT port Ship of Harkinian).

It set up a timer ever 30 minutes to check in on itself and see if it gave up. It reviews progress every 4 hours and revisits prioritization. I hadn't checked on it in days and when I looked today it was still going, a few functions at a time.

It set up those times itself and creates new ones as needed.

It's not any one particular thing that is novel, but it's just more independent because of all the little bits.

hobofan|14 days ago

So, you don't know if it has produced anything valuable yet?

hirako2000|14 days ago

$3 z.ai subscription? Sounds like it already burned $3k

I find those toys in perfect alignment with what LLM provider thrive for. Widespread token consumption explosion to demonstrate investors: see, we told you we were right to invest, let's open other giga factories.

thinkingtoilet|14 days ago

What a great use of humanity's adn the earth's resources.

someperson|14 days ago

Keep us posted, this sounds great!

jdgoesmarching|14 days ago

Not being tied to Anthropic’s models and ecosystems, having more control over the agent, interacting with it from you messaging app of choice.

aydyn|14 days ago

There's some neat experiments people post on social media. Mostly, the thing that captures the imagination the most is its sort of like watching a silicon child grow up.

They develop their own personalities, they express themselves creatively, they choose for themselves, they choose what they believe and who they become.

I know that sounds like anthropomorphism, and maybe it is, but it most definitely does not feel like interacting with a coding agent. Claude is just the substrate.

wiseowise|14 days ago

> Mostly, the thing that captures the imagination the most is it’s sort of like watching a silicon child grow up.

> They develop their own personalities, they express themselves creatively, they choose for themselves, they choose what they believe and who they become.

Jesus Christ, the borderline idiotic are now downgraded to deranged. US government needs to redirect stargate’s 500B to mental institutions asap.

esafak|14 days ago

Imagine putting it in a robot with arms and legs, and letting it loose in your house, or your neighborhood. Oh, the possibilities!