[mustaphah]

Yeah, I got your point when I read the paper. You're essentially controlling for "latent domain knowledge."

I might have been a bit blunt with the title - sorry about that, but I still think it was a good title. From what I've observed, a lot of Skills on GitHub are just AI-generated without any feedback or deliberative refinement. Many thought those would still be valuable, but you've shown evidence otherwise.

[xdotli]

no worries it's totally fine! there is indeed work needs to be done on the feedbacks generated skills. Thanks for helping us submitting on HackerNews. And for > a lot of Skills on GitHub are just AI-generated without any feedback or deliberative refinement. Many thought those would still be valuable, but you've shown evidence otherwise. we do find most skills on the internet to be useless, and thanks to the generosity of https://skillsmp.com/ author, we were able to get all the meta data of the 99k skills indexed on his website. We did a lot of filtering and deduping and we discovered ~40k+ skills were relevant at the time we did the study.