WingNews logo WingNews
top | item 47066945

(no title)

mrsmrtss | 11 days ago

Probably not, but it’d be closer to Clojure. Depending on codebase you’ll likely have also many repeating namespace imports (can be avoided whith implicit usings in modern C#) etc.

discuss

order

so-cal-schemer|5 days ago

Here's a better gauge for code density:

https://benchmarksgame-team.pages.debian.net/benchmarksgame/...

How source-code size is measured

We start with the source-code markup you can see, remove comments, remove duplicate whitespace characters, and then apply minimum GZip compression. The measurement is the size in bytes of that GZip compressed source-code file.

Thanks to Brian Hurt for the idea of using size of compressed source-code instead of lines of code.

  median
  February 2025
  ===============
  Toit        558
  Perl        570
  Lua         580
  PHP         581
  Ruby        583
  Python 3    585
  Julia       634
  Chapel      646
  Racket      696
  JavaScript  698
  OCaml       741
  Erlang      798
  Go          831
  Dart        847
  Smalltalk   871
  Haskell     892
  Java        910
  Lisp        938
  Swift       939
  F#          943
  Pascal      959
  Fortran    1091
  C#         1117
  C          1121
  C++        1129
  Rust       1235
  Ada        1825

mrsmrtss|5 days ago

The Benchmarks Game has some highly optimized implementations and is not a good representation of typical code. Some languages allow you to go a lot lower than others if needed, which adds verbosity, that does not mean typical code must be verbose. There are things possible in C# that you just can't do in Java, for example. That does not mean typical Java code is more concise than C#. On the contrary, typical C# would be probably considerably more "dense".

so-cal-schemer|11 days ago

I'd expect programming style to have a lot to do with it. Many modern languages are evolving toward Lisp and support ever more of its features. Generic programming and meta programming for instance.

(I think the tool used accounts for imports and defines.)