top | item 47071656

(no title)

pablomalo | 12 days ago

Pascal's wager, as it relates to faith, is based on the premise that there is a lot to win in making the wager --but little to lose. In turn, that second part is grounded in the assumption (right or wrong, I won't judge) that living according to Christian principles brings benefits _in this life also_ to the individual who so chooses.

So it seems a mischaracterization to present the essence of the wager as going out of your way to perform random and costly rites in the hope of lifting any ill omen.

discuss

order

aeternum|11 days ago

I disagree. If doing thing x brings benefits, then you have reason to do thing x regardless of the wager. Utilitarianism is sufficient.

The wager is only interesting on those rites where the expected-value is uncertain or unknowable.

joquarky|12 days ago

Exactly. For example, what if making such wagers is key in determining that you belong in "hell" for not being genuine?

johsole|11 days ago

> living according to Christian principles brings benefits _in this life also_

It does, in this life and the next.