[padjo]

So by your logic if you slowly exterminate a people its not genocide?

[mattmaroon]

You cannot exterminate a people too slowly because they can (and do) move. Ethnic cleansing can happen over centuries (see the last 500 years of our hemisphere for examples). Israel has let tens of thousands of them out of the country. Nazis did not let injured Jews go to hospitals in other countries.

Which, again, is not dismissing war crimes, or denying that any have occurred. Just pointing out, this is not genocide but ethnic cleansing. Israel has a vocal right wing faction that advocates for ethnic cleansing, and a vocal left wing that is against it.

[manyaoman]

That definition of genocide is so narrow that it would also exclude the Armenian genocide, since many were allowed to flee.