top | item 47148429

(no title)

Gud | 5 days ago

The USA still has a lot of high end manufacturing going on. There is no “used to”.

discuss

order

embedding-shape|5 days ago

Sure, but it's seemingly doing less and less. "Value Added by Industry: Manufacturing as a Percentage of GDP" has been going downwards for a long long time, here is the last twenty years: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/VAPGDPMA

moregrist|4 days ago

I don’t think you can take “percentage of GDP” as an indication that the US is doing less. It could be doing the same amount while the GDP grew tremendously in other areas, for example software.

And if you look at the absolute contribution in dollars, manufacturing has gone up 1.76 times between 2005 and today: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USMANNQGSP

This is roughly 2.9% a year over 20 years, so slightly ahead of inflation over the period.

To me this points to a story where manufacturing grew slightly but the other parts of the economy grew a lot more. Not exactly a bear case on manufacturing, but not a tremendously exciting one either.

Gud|4 days ago

I concur with moregrist

bad_haircut72|4 days ago

At the end of the day the reason people see manufacturing as special is because in a war it is a strategic resource. If this wasnt the case nobody would care about "manufacturing jobs" any more than the general economy. So if you use defence production as your metric... "U.S. Navy Shipbuilding Is Consistently Over Budget and Delayed Despite Billions Invested in Industry"

https://www.gao.gov/blog/u.s.-navy-shipbuilding-consistently...