top | item 47151919

(no title)

RHSeeger | 4 days ago

To me it boils down to (pun intended)

> Traditional dictionaries skip almost all such phrases, because they contain spaces.

Yes, because they're phrases, not words. I don't even understand what's surprising about this. Sure, the entire article talks about how dictionaries contain _some_ phrases; but it's clear it's not many of them. Dictionaries are for words, not phrases.

discuss

order

win311fwg|4 days ago

Technically they are both phrases and words. You can call them lexemes if you want to avoid confusing the computer programmers who do not understand that life isn't binary.

RHSeeger|4 days ago

While this is certainly outside my wheelhouse, what I see in various locations is that (at least for English)

- A multi-word phrase is a phrase, not a word

- A lexeme is a basic unit of meaning in a language, like a word (and it's forms [1]) or phrase.

- Every place I was able to find described a lexeme as a "word _OR_ phrase", making it clear those two are different things.

- Dictionaries, in general, focus on words. Many do include phrases also. This point is less definitive; and just my understanding from looking at dictionaries and how they describe themselves. That being said, every source I can find that discussed something close to the topic seems to support this

[1] A word with all it's forms, in that "walk", "walked", and "walks" are all a single lexeme (with each form being a distinct word) OR a phrase

Side note: I'm not looking to "correct" anyone; just pointing out what information I'm able to find on the topic. I'm open to being corrected, but that correction would need to include reasonable sources.