top | item 47156769

(no title)

alpaca128 | 4 days ago

Asking an AI to name itself is already strange to me. It makes me think the user treats the AI as something that deserves enough rights or respect that assigning it a name might feel wrong, or at least that the AI has sufficient intelligence to make such a decision.

discuss

order

strongpigeon|4 days ago

Oh I agree that it's strange, but is it harmful? I'm not being rhetorical, I'm genuinely unsure.

Tangentially, I noticed recently that I'm always fairly respectful in my LLM prompts and often say "thank you" as part of them. LLMs don't need that, but I've come to realize that I'm saying those thing for me. I don't like being disrespectful and expressing gratitude is important to me. Is expressing gratitude to a LLM strange? Perhaps. Is it harmful though? I don't think so.

But yeah, asking an LLM for their name? That seems like something else.

blooalien|4 days ago

> I noticed recently that I'm always fairly respectful in my LLM prompts and often say "thank you" as part of them.

I recently saw a comic where the machines took over and "that guy" (you) in the comic was the one the machines allowed to live because "he was always polite". ;)