top | item 47167898

I don't need AI to build me a new app. I need it to make Jira bearable

21 points| niel_hu | 3 days ago

Last week I asked Claude to build me a Jira sidebar that shows cross-project dependency graphs — the kind Jira buries across 4 clicks and 3 page loads. 4 prompts. Works inside my actual Jira. It just used Claude Chrome extension that injects a panel into the page I already have open.

And I keep thinking: why isn't everyone doing this?

The entire AI coding conversation is about building new apps from scratch. Cool. But I don't need a new app. Most people spend their workday inside apps they didn't choose: Jira, Salesforce, Workday, ServiceNow, etc. These tools are not going anywhere. My company chose them in 2019 and they're entrenched until at least 2029.

Chrome extensions just reads what's already in the DOM and augments it.

Is there a fundamental reason this can't work at scale that I'm not seeing? Why isn't Claude's Chrome extension catching more attention?

21 comments

order

Nathanf22|7 hours ago

The dependency graph point resonates. There's a broader pattern here: the tools we use daily were designed around human navigation — menus, pages, clicks. But dependency relationships are fundamentally graph problems, and graphs don't render well in hierarchical UIs. Jira buries cross-project dependencies across 4 clicks because it was built around projects as the primary unit, not relationships. The data is there. The mental model isn't. The Chrome extension approach is clever precisely because it doesn't fight the entrenched tool — it layers the missing mental model on top. Same data, different lens. I've been thinking about this problem from the codebase side: your source code has the same issue. The architecture of a system is a graph, but we navigate it through a file tree. The file tree is a terrible lens for understanding how things connect. It's why onboarding on a new codebase takes weeks even when the code is clean. The real unlock — in Jira, in codebases, anywhere — is switching from the hierarchical lens to the relational one. We're just starting to build tooling that makes that switch easy.

CodeBit26|2 days ago

This resonates so much. We’ve spent years automating the 'coding' part, but the 'process' part is still stuck in a click-heavy 2010s workflow. I don't want an AI that writes boilerplate; I want an AI that observes my Git commits and Slack discussions, then automatically updates the ticket status, linked PRs, and documentation. The real productivity killer in 2026 isn't the lack of code assistants, it's the 'administrative tax' of keeping project management tools in sync with reality

KurSix|2 days ago

Dumping a continuous firehose of Slack messages into an LLM context is a guaranteed way to bankrupt the company. Plus, the latency is a joke: by the time the agent parses the thread and hits the Jira API, you could've manually dragged the tickets across the board three times over yourself

satvikpendem|21 hours ago

This is literally an LLM comment, the structure is the same.

PaulHoule|3 days ago

It's definitely part of the SaaS-apocalypse story. LLMs shine at making little programs that integrate with an existing API to do some small task. Management has always overestimated the effort to develop that kind of thing and underestiamted the effort to develop applications with GUIs because... user interfaces are the Vietnam of computer science.

The greatest danger of the current time is that the likes of Salesforce and LinkedIn who have something interesting behind an API or web site try to lock down access so instead of using competitive high-quality AI agents we're stuck with the brain damaged AI agents they want to force on us.

niel_hu|3 days ago

Yeah, totally agree. But I don't think they can keep it locked down any more, with the rise of computer use agents, the boundary between interfaces designed for humans and those designed for computers is becoming increasingly blurred.

KurSix|2 days ago

Just because Claude hacked together a panel on top of Jira doesn't make it a scalable pattern. Most of these on-the-fly generated UIs are slow as hell, hijack native page events, and leak memory like crazy. It's fine for a personal PoC, but rolling this out to an entire team is pure insanity

xp84|2 days ago

As though Jira itself is a model of well-architected and performant frontend!

pants2|2 days ago

I vibe-coded my own Jira interface at work. Everyone likes it better and half the company is using it now lol.

niel_hu|2 days ago

Curious about your approach. How did you implemented it ? how did it talk to Jira backend ?

andrei_says_|3 days ago

Did you create a new extension or a custom script for an existing one?

niel_hu|3 days ago

Neither. I asked claude through extension to modify the page directly

verdverm|3 days ago

Rovo is sad you never pick it for these kinds of things

niel_hu|3 days ago

Rovo from atlassian? no thanks.