What our DNA reveals about the sex life of Neanderthals

[Hooke]

https://archive.is/9mQKV

[rayiner]

I can’t believe people are being so flippant describing this story (“sex life”) when there’s a high probability that the differential is because neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females. Neanderthals had much higher muscle mass and were much stronger than homo sapiens.

[SoftTalker]

We don't know that, and we don't know that neanderthal males were more prone to rape than homo sapiens males. And it's weird to even apply the 21st century concept of rape to prehistoric societies.

[lifestyleguru]

> the differential is because neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females

They were simply more attractive to homo sapiens females because of more chest hair, muscles, and better defined jawline.

[TurdF3rguson]

> neanderthal males were raping homo sapiens females.

I guess you'd rather not even be here?

[rngfnby]

Well, ya. Of course it was rape. And in retaliation we genocided them, hence the lack of Y and mRNA.

[Terr_]

Before anyone jaunts too far down the road of literal survivorship bias, I'd like to point out that it'd be incredibly premature—or perhaps way too late—to speculate much on the social side of things.

Elsewhere I've seen some people making hay about exactly whose-males were with whose-females, and want to point out that it's normal for genes to cause asymmetries.

In particular, consider the modern problem of RH incompatibility [0], where one pairing is more likely to end up with a child than an identical but gender-bent one.

[0] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/21053-rh-fact...

[maxrf]

or even as simple as mitochondria...

[jyscao]

Presumably this hypothesis is meant to explain why there is this observed asymmetry in the type of Neanderthal DNA we find in modern human populations that contain them, which is entirely autosomal. With none in the mitochondrial form, which is exclusively passed down along the female line, and also none in the Y-chromosome form, which is exclusively passed down along the male line.

Without weighing on the validity of their hypothesis that one or both sides found the other“especially attractive”, an alternative mechanism that could explain why we only see Neanderthal autosomal DNA in modern humans could be that only the female offspring of male-Neanderthal and female-sapiens pairings were reproductively fertile. This is more commonly the case in interspecies hybrids, see Haldane’s rule.

[microgpt]

why no mitochondrial then?

[marojejian]

Boy it so tempting to come up with "just so" stories to explain this. And so frustrating that we will probably never be able to determine the answer. but still cool.

[nemosaltat]

In those days, there were γίγαντες and also after.

[jjtheblunt]

evidently, i'm not the only one who has watched Ancient Aliens (though with the fam for historical mysteries blended with hilarity)

[catcowcostume]

Is there any non-paywalled link for this?

[jyscao]

Any browser with reader mode should also work. Worked for me on Brave, both mobile and desktop.

[garciasn]

https://archive.is/9mQKV

For future reference: head on over to archive.is or .ph and you, too, can get around the paywall.

[Beijinger]

I recommend the "Pass paywalls clean" plug-in