top | item 47191018

(no title)

fc417fc802 | 1 day ago

By that logic sin(x) is equivalent to a lookup table. Yeah, you can approximate it that way. But doing so at any reasonable level of precision will quickly become an exercise in the absurd. Neural networks are far worse, consisting of stacks of massive linear combinations fed into nonlinear functions.

Regardless, it remains irrelevant to the subject at hand. You're going off on a tangent rather than admit your initial claim was wrong.

discuss

order

qsera|1 day ago

>By that logic sin(x) is equivalent to a lookup table

NO!

`sin(x)` is continuous, so the domain is infinite.

But an LLM model is not a continuous function, and thus the domain of a LLM model is finite (set of all possible tokens). So using a lookup table for a model behavior would be exact and not an approximation. So it can indeed be represented by an if statement of finite size.

Hence proved!

If you don't understand something in what I wrote, I can clarify if you tell me where you have trouble following.