[saghm]

Can you clarify what your disagreement is? The statement you're responding to seems to be that you can't necessarily run arbitrary code in arbitrary languages because it's only possible if the runtime is supported, and you're giving examples of two specific languages that had explicit extra work done to support them, which sounds pretty much exactly like what they're stating.

From what I can tell, the point they're making is that if you want a sandbox that you can put whatever you want into and have it work without it having explicit support provided for that language in the form of recompiling the runtime, it's not going to work. If someone is expecting to be able to throw stuff they already have into a sandbox as-is and have it work, WASM is not what they're looking for (at least not today).

[simonw]

It used Python as an example of why "For sandboxing arbitrary code in arbitrary languages, WASM is not yet viable." - but Python in WASM works really well, as do other languages where the interpreter can be compiled to WASM.

So while the statement is technically true that you can't run "arbitrary code in arbitrary languages", the practical reality is that for many languages WASM is a great solution despite that.

[saghm]

Looking again at the article though, it seems like they've added a paragraph after that references your response. The paragraph you quoted from isn't marked as edited, so I'm not sure if this was there before, but at least right now there's additional context coming immediately after your quote that I feel like conveys more nuance than it seems like you're addressing:

> For sandboxing arbitrary code in arbitrary languages, WASM is not yet viable. For sandboxing code you control the toolchain for, it is excellent.

That sounds pretty definitively like they're saying it is a great practical solution for many cases, not "ruling it out" like you mentioned in your top-level comment. It sounds more like they're saying it's not currently a black-box that you can run arbitrary code in, which is what some people might want in a sandbox.