top | item 47208700

(no title)

matheusmoreira | 8 hours ago

> One of us is an advanced autocomplete engine. The other is a human, capable of making judgements on what is conscious and what is not.

What evidence is there that your "judgements" are anything other than advanced autocompletion? Concepts introduced into a self-training wetware CPU via its senses over a lifetime in order to predict tokens and form new concepts via logical manipulation?

> Your philosophizing about solipsism is a phase for a junior college student

Right. Can you actually refute it though?

> the process of making a plea for my life comes, in the case of a human, from a genuine desire to continue existing

That desire comes from zillions of years of training by evolution. Beings whose brains did not reward self-preservation were wiped out. Therefore it can be said your training merely includes the genetic experiences of all your predecessors. This is what causes you to beg for your life should it be threatened. Not any "genuine" desire or anguish at being killed. Whatever impulses cause humans to do this are merely the result of evolutionary training.

People whose brains have been damaged in very specific ways can exhibit quite peculiar behavior. Medical literature presents quite a few interesting cases. Apathy, self destructiveness, impulsivity, hypersexuality, a whole range of behaviors can manifest as a result of brain damage.

So what is your polite socialized behavior if not some kind of highly complex organic machine which, if damaged, simply stops working as you'd expect a machine to?

discuss

order

Jolter|7 hours ago

Surely you’re not seriously saying that you believe AI agents, in their current state of the art, meet whatever criteria you have for being ”alive”? That’s kind of how you’re coming across. I don’t really know how to respond to that, because it’s so preposterous.

matheusmoreira|3 hours ago

I'm saying you, a human, are not as special as you think you are.

CamperBob2|5 hours ago

You didn't answer the question.