[jasonshen]

Many breakthrough technologies appear initially like toys. And this certainly qualifies. I've never been able to code anything more complicated than a memory game in javascript but I have worked with engineering teams for my entire professional career. But prompting my agent to write python scripts to pull down data from various tools via API without having to read docs, do trial and error for hours / days / indefinitely, and actually produce something coherent in seconds? Incredible.

Is my OpenClaw agent currently changing my life? No. It sends me a morning briefing based on my calendar, the weather, my Readwise highlights, and notes on who I'm talking to today based on call transcripts. I use it as a food diary (which I could have done on platform LLMs but this feels like a more personalized UX as we can write the logs to text files on my personal computer). I can absolutely see how transformative this agent can become in the next few years. Certainly my usage of LLMs has changed my life since ChatGPT first launched.

You are seeing the loudest / most hyped users. There's a reason it has so many stars and most of the people getting something out of it are not posting on X. They're just using it to do the thing.

[blenderob]

> There's a reason it has so many stars and most of the people getting something out of it are not posting on X.

That reason is buying stars, agent swarms, and astroturing.

No project gathers 200K stars genuinely in 3 months. There are far more useful and popular projects that need 10 years to get 200K stars. When you see a project like this get 200K stars in just 3 months, you know something is very fishy.

[adampunk]

Yes, you’re right. It’s the children who are wrong.

Why is it so difficult to imagine that something that looks popular and fun is popular and fun?

Also, really who is paying for stars on open claw? Who benefits here?

[skeledrew]

Or you're just missing the generally wide appeal of the project.

[Xirdus]

Do you have any examples of 20th or 21st century breakthrough technologies that started out as toys? I can only think of 3D printers.

[monkpit]

3D printing started as aerospace tech, I’m pretty sure.

[DomB]

Drones