top | item 4916281

(no title)

tharris0101 | 13 years ago

Sort of off-topic and I've harped on this before, but when I search "google maps" in the app store, it's the fifth search result!

As a developer in the App Store, I really hope they do something to fix the abysmal searches in it.

discuss

order

wes-exp|13 years ago

Agreed! This happens with my own app as well! Apparently the app title, even when an exact match to your search query, is no longer considered important.

If there is one thing Apple truly fails at, it is search.

wahsd|13 years ago

...don't forget maps. They failed at that too. But I can tell you that it was not necessarily Apple that failed at maps. The same problems I had with Apple maps were there in Magellan GPS and their map and content provider Navteq....which is Apple Maps' map, nav, and data provider.

Ever notice when you were doing the turn-by-turn directions that there is a lag in the marker that leads you to miss or almost miss turns, especially in complex intersections....that lag was a huge issue 8 years ago, as it is today. In all that time, Navteq did very little, it seems, to improve routing, maps, or navigation. I was just using Apple Maps yesterday (I'm a very patient and open minded person that gives several unbiased opportunities) when I was told to go around this very short road segment. Turns out it was probably because the segment it marked as "No Thru Trucks". Those Navteq annoyances are what made Magellan GPS horrible and after who knows how long of doing nothing to improve them, Navteq has brought Apple to its knees.

eco|13 years ago

The Android Market had this same problem in the early days. It was frustrating but pretty amusing how terrible Google, of all companies, was at getting search right in their app store.

Terretta|13 years ago

I believe that was a deliberate tweak in response to the throngs of spam apps titling themselves by the key search terms of popular apps -- and the throngs of users complaining when they idiotically bought one of the spam apps instead of the real app.

nikcub|13 years ago

If only they partnered with a company that was really good at search and maps and could fill in the parts that Apple isn't good at ..

BryantD|13 years ago

And Apple could monopolize the areas that company wasn't good at yet, like smartphone OSes!

walru|13 years ago

As a developer I couldn't agree more.. the App Store is currently an unmitigated mess.

pkamb|13 years ago

The best is the Keywords field that cannot be longer than "100 bytes", doesn't validate your character count until you submit the from, is unclear about comma/space separated values, and disregards pluralization.

ivankirigin|13 years ago

It isn't off topic to point out that Apple isn't as good at search as Google. Relevant to both maps and app stores.

hiddenstage|13 years ago

Maybe Google will come to the rescue.

darrenkopp|13 years ago

Their search on the Google Play store isn't that great, though they now have a feature where what they auto-suggest when typing your query is usually what you want (for larger apps like netflix, ebay, etc)

dkokelley|13 years ago

My best results for search appear when the App Store auto suggests terms that others have entered. So "docs to..." suggests "Documents to Go(r) by DataViz" or something of the sort. I think that Apple could learn a thing or two from Google's search-intent capabilities.

ibrahima|13 years ago

I remember when Android's market had a similarly terrible search for years, which I thought was funnier considering it was Google and all (although I think their usual algorithms don't work nearly as well for apps that don't really have natural links).

seanp2k2|13 years ago

I noticed this too and was annoyed by it.

coob|13 years ago

I think this happens due to the way the App Store time-weights many metrics. expect it to be top tomorrow.

neilc|13 years ago

That makes sense, but it makes for pretty terrible UX for major app launches like this one.