top | item 5350970

(no title)

DeepDuh | 13 years ago

I've just watched that clip for the first time: http://www.topgear.com/uk/videos/electric-shocker?VideoBrows...

Defamation? Really? I think Clarkson was actually pretty fair, considering his usual style. What they showed at least seems believable to me.

discuss

order

jlgreco|13 years ago

Yeah, I for one think that Musk was being entirely unreasonable when he got upset with Top Gear (I mean come on, this is a show that gave a good review to a car because they were able to drive it upside-down in a tunnel...).

His issues with the Times seem far more reasonable.

waterlesscloud|13 years ago

"gave a good review to a car because they were able to drive it upside-down in a tunnel"

Musk aside, is there a youtube link for that?

sliverstorm|13 years ago

actually pretty fair, considering his usual style

Which, sadly, brings us back to what they say about why Top Gear US can't be like Top Gear UK. Try that style in the US, and everybody is jumping down your throat.

DeepDuh|13 years ago

Honestly, as a European, that sums up pretty much the preconceptions we have about Americans: throat jumpy. If it accurately reflects American culture is another story, but I gotta say American media is not really helping the case - as isn't Mr. Musk here.

That being said, I - and most of my acquaintances - still love American culture - the kind of 'just do it'(TM) attitude, shown as well by Elon here - the stunts he's pulling with three high risk industrial companies at the same time is pretty much unthinkable in 'the old world'. And I'm not sure, but maybe his aggressive stance, the ability to sort of indoctrinate himself with his vision, might actually be needed to push through these grand projects. It's not unlike what we've known from Steve Jobs, really. Most people would agree that he was quite an ass - but by god he was an influential one.