top | item 6195655

(no title)

thufry | 12 years ago

What is the purpose of the word "mansplaining" in the opening paragraph? It sounds like the author is claiming sexist dismissiveness while offering no evidence of such.

discuss

order

81289h1221dj0|12 years ago

Thank you. I just came here to complain about this as well. I've heard the term 'mansplaining' before. In fact I even read a comment where someone was attacked ("You're mansplaining 'mansplaining' to me.") because he commented on the term. The very _concept_ of explaining is now suspect. God help us.

IvyMike|12 years ago

Obviously we can't know O'Donnell's motives for being condescending and dismissive.

But that's just another reason that's a bad idea to be a jerk--people might misattribute the motivations behind your dickishness.

thufry|12 years ago

This is why I personally refuse to engage in any discussions about race or gender issues except online. Low reward, with a high risk of a career-ending brand as a sexist or racist asshole.

akuchling|12 years ago

She quotes the host of the show as saying "Julia, Julia, Julia. You aren't seriously suggesting that Vladimir Putin and the Russian government did not have complete, total, absolute control over the outcome of Edward Snowden entering that airport in Moscow?" That certainly sounds dismissive and infantilizing.

thufry|12 years ago

Sure, but I see people going at each other like this all the time on TV, regardless of gender - we no longer have the mutual respect of the Edward R. Murrow days. I think this is actually how Bill O Reilly speaks to every single one of his (predominantly male) guests.

81289h1221dj0|12 years ago

Maybe. But I can't see how this is related to her being a woman.