top | item 6772112

Elio Motors: $6800 car, 84 mpg

50 points| zeppelin_7 | 12 years ago |eliomotors.com

55 comments

order
[+] lumberjack|12 years ago|reply
At that price tag I see it competing with used cars. If you are looking for cheap transportation you can get a used car in a decent condition for ~$2000. That would leave you with $4800 to spend on gas. According to the EIA the average household spends $3000 on gas per year. Dividing by two and assuming two cars and two daily commutes, the $4800 would only last for around three years.

So that means that it would take three years for somebody to break even and start saving cash on gas if you decide to go with the Elio instead of a used car.

So whether this concept will sell or not depends in part on whether the customers will view it as a long term investment or a short term fix until they are better off financially.

And I really don't buy their second commuter-only-car pitch. Somebody who can afford a new $20K vehicle can also afford the $700 (they claim $800 in gas per year) yearly penalty on gas, so the only people I see being attracted by this concept are people short on money which probably drive used cars.

http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=9831

[+] JacobSkyler|12 years ago|reply
If I had to guess I would say it's intending to fill the niche of the family's second car. Something for Dad to drive to work in while Mum drives the kids around in the main car. The person who's so poor that they can only afford a $2,000 car probably can't afford to make an investment that will take 3 years to pay off.
[+] cylinder|12 years ago|reply
Can you show me an example of a decent condition used car that's going to be reliable @ $2000?
[+] nazgulnarsil|12 years ago|reply
why would anyone get a new corvette when for the same price you can get a used ferrari?
[+] simantel|12 years ago|reply
The site didn't load for me, but I found their YouTube[1] channel to have a gander. They remind me a lot of the microcars[2] of the 40s and 50s, the most famous of which would be BMW's Isetta[3]. In terms of style, however, I the Elio reminds me a bit of the Messerschmitt KR200[4].

[1] https://www.youtube.com/user/eliomotors

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microcar

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isetta

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_KR200

[+] amalag|12 years ago|reply
I think they REALLY should have put a CVT in it. I don't know why they are still in the manual / automatic mode. CVTs are great for low powered cars. They have less moving parts than automatic transmissions. They are standard on Mitsubishis and Nissans now.
[+] Jagat|12 years ago|reply
Tata motors has been selling a $2000, 66mpg car called Nano in India since 2008.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Nano

[+] amalag|12 years ago|reply
Even in India people don't like it very much. They say it runs like an auto rickshaw with a body. It has 2 cydlinders and 37hp.
[+] Zigurd|12 years ago|reply
Priced too low. You can get nice used cars at the price. Any Toyota or Honda engine should run to 200-250k miles. I doubt this thing will make it to 100k.

If Honda made a semi-enclosed three wheeler for the "damn it I'm riding no matter the weather" audience, they would have a chance. They could also sell it for at least $10k and still sell a lot of them. The Elio is a solution to no particular problem.

[+] kamaal|12 years ago|reply
Their site says 5000+ people have already ordered it. So its already solving their problems, no?

Besides used cars are still 'used' cars. And its not just engine running 200-250K miles. By 100K miles the juice from the engine is gone. It can still run an additional 150K miles, may be. But for a very different definition of 'run'.

And you still have to drive some one else's used car, for mileage no where close to Elio. Plus all other wear and tear hassles of an old car.

Here you get a brand new one for a decent price which can run for the next 2 years. And for 6.8K dollars its a super cheap investment to make.

[+] iknight|12 years ago|reply
"Uncaught SecurityError: Blocked a frame with origin "http://www.youtube.com" from accessing a frame with origin "http://www.eliomotors.com". Protocols, domains, and ports must match."

looking for web development help?

[+] dangrossman|12 years ago|reply
Are you offering to help YouTube? That error indicates code on youtube.com is being blocked from accessing the page embedding the video (which would, for example, stop Google from accessing your personal info on every site that embeds a YouTube video). It's not something the containing page is doing wrong.
[+] hongquan|12 years ago|reply
Wonder how this came up today, these guys have been around since 2008, or a year before I started my three wheeler "car" company. I am surprised to see they have one that runs, but the road to production will be long and rough. I'll bet anyone $100 that they won't ship a production version by "Summer of 2014".
[+] patrickg_zill|12 years ago|reply
For myself, I would be interested in this car due to low price, high expected reliability (not a lot to go wrong), excellent fuel economy and the ability to use HOV lanes. I have an SUVish vehicle and frankly it is overkill for what I typically carry.
[+] lttlrck|12 years ago|reply
They should have left out the size comparison with the Cadillac CTS. Almost the same size?!
[+] null_ptr|12 years ago|reply
Looks cool and I'd love to have one to zoom to work and around the city, but I would hate to be in an accident against a normal car, let alone a multi-ton SUV, and that's what pretty much everyone else drives.
[+] aeturnum|12 years ago|reply
There are other small cars, like those manufactured by Smart, that do quite well in crash tests. The car probably won't survive, but it's relatively cheap to build a top-quality protective cage around the driver when the interior is this small.
[+] glibgil|12 years ago|reply
This is not a car. It is a motorcycle with roll cage and airbags. It may be safer than a bike or normal motorcycle, but not a modern car.
[+] __xtrimsky|12 years ago|reply
There is no way I'm driving this in the US next to large SUV/Hummers.

It's nice, but if someone slightly bumps into you, you're dead :/

[+] VladRussian2|12 years ago|reply
i kind of hate to put myself at risk of overturning at 80mph on mild windy day on mild turn on 280 just because 3 wheeler (motorcycle) is easier (read cheaper) to certify than 4 wheeler (car). Of course that is also because i can afford to pay additional money of "car price", and i'd probably thought differently if i couldn't.

Not saying that such a vehicle don't have its place. Though i have hard time imagining it. If not highway - than cities - European cities are well populated either by small 4-wheel cars or just scooters. Doesn't seem like there is niche for car size 3 wheeler without full benefits of a car.

[+] hingisundhorsa|12 years ago|reply
I looked up the point you are making. The data backs you up, 3 wheelers suffer from inherent instability on turns. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQh56geU0X8 "When the single wheel is in the front , the vehicle is inherently unstable in a braking turn, as the combined tipping forces at the center of gravity from turning and braking can rapidly extend beyond the triangle formed by the contact patches of the wheels. This type, if not tipped, also has a greater tendency to spin out ("swap ends") when handled roughly." What a pity. I was quite excited about the prospects.
[+] amalag|12 years ago|reply
When the two wheels are in the front it behaves completely different from asian scooters which have two wheels in the back.
[+] pkaye|12 years ago|reply
Is it a one person car?
[+] a3n|12 years ago|reply
Mostly. Video shows a convertible back seat "for your kid."

Video also compares this against a similarly priced used car, but if you need more than one real seat for a family, this isn't it.

It's a toy for Silicon Valley.

[+] toblender|12 years ago|reply
I think it is, I can't find any details about this on the site.
[+] oftenwrong|12 years ago|reply
Two seater. The back seat is directly behind the driver seat.
[+] ibudiallo|12 years ago|reply
Wordpress does not handle hackernews very well.
[+] fuzzix|12 years ago|reply
Not to defend Wordpress as I'm not particularly a fan, but it's not all that complex to use Wordpress/Apache behind nginx with a reasonable caching strategy.

Even on a cheap VPS I've configured it to handle tens of thousands of requests per minute.

[+] chc|12 years ago|reply
The kind of traffic generated by Hacker News is way more than you need to kill a standard WordPress setup.
[+] evan2m|12 years ago|reply
The infamous HN DDoS strikes again
[+] athst|12 years ago|reply
the "anticipated 5-star" safety rating doesn't feel very comforting...
[+] jws|12 years ago|reply
Generally speaking…

three wheeled "car" ⇒ couldn't pass car safety requirements, legally a motorcycle

[+] jzawodn|12 years ago|reply
I read that as "it hasn't been officially crash tested yet..."
[+] dewyatt|12 years ago|reply
Here is a quick rundown from cache:

Number of current reservations: 4815 (As of Nov 05, 2013)

Elio is not a fling. It is not a novelty. =========================================

It is the product of a mobile society naturally evolving to a more efficient and practical form of transportation.

Let’s look at the facts and realities of the world we live in:

Gas today is at an all-time high Space is becoming a smaller and smaller commodity and we’re being crowded off our roads and bumped and dinged out of our parking lots Cars cost more than the average house did only a few decades ago Traditional personal transportation isn’t working like it used to. We need a new way of getting around.

That’s when a car enthusiast, a visionary, a man with a dream named Paul Elio got an idea. A simple, brilliant idea. To create a vehicle for today’s generation of drivers that addressed their transportation needs and the world’s new realities.

The result is Elio ===============

And it’s more than merely a fun, fuel-efficient way to get around. Elio can have a profound effect on our economy – creating approximately 1500 jobs in Louisiana alone. And we all know the ripple effect a vehicle has when you factor in everyone from the suppliers and their employees to all the other businesses that prosper from putting previously unemployed people to work.

Elio is a major step in curbing the erosion of our environment and making us far less dependent on foreign oil. Just think how that will affect the political landscape of our world!

From the economy to the environment to the national debt to foreign relations, Elio is an idea whose time has come – and that time is now!

Specs =====

84 Miles per Gallon It gets 84 miles to the gallon on the highway. That means you can go from Detroit to New York City on a tank of gas – or drive from Shreveport LA to Dallas and back – then back to Dallas again – and still have about 110 miles left before a refill. How is that possible? Keep reading.

Anticipated 5 Star Crash Test Rating Each Elio comes equipped with a Safety Management System that includes three airbags – a reinforced roll-cage frame, Anti-Lock Braking System, and 50% larger crush zones than similar vehicles. Preliminary safety tests on computer models anticipate a 5-Star safety rating.

8-Gallon Tank It can go 672 miles, or thereabouts, because it has an 8-gallon tank and 8X84=672. Of course, other factors will affect your mileage but you get the point.

American Made = American Jobs It should come as no surprise that Elio will create a number of much-needed jobs for American workers. We’re estimating 1,500 jobs at our Shreveport, LA plant beginning in 2014.

Power in Numbers An inline, 3 cylinder, .9 liter, 55 HP, fuel-injected, SOHC gas-powered, liquid-cooled, automotive engine.

Eco-Friendly This is a very green vehicle – and we’re not just talking about the color. Yes, it gets 84 MPG on the highway, but you’ll be doing your share of city driving, too. Fear not, with its city rate of 49 MPG, you’ll be consuming only 1/3 of what the average American vehicle consumes.

Only $6,800 It only costs $6,800. That’s about what you would pay for an outboard motor to power a rowboat.

Our Transmission Mission 5-speed manual or automatic. And yes, it has a reverse gear.