top | item 9447025

(no title)

saraid216 | 11 years ago

In America, there's no longer much legitimacy placed in legislation; we generally look to the judiciary for any actual governing thought these days.

Legislation is mostly seen as a stepping stone; it's not until it's been tested in court that a law is really valid.

discuss

order

talmand|11 years ago

I find that sort of statement deeply disturbing.

saraid216|11 years ago

Well, yes. So do I. That's why I felt I had to say it.

titanomachy|11 years ago

It's also encouraging in a way. It's good to know that there are checks in place to prevent the enforcement of laws that violate our fundamental rights.

ska|11 years ago

I suspect that some legislation has been written with this in mind for quite a while now. The laws themselves being an exercise in Overton window type thinking, not with any view that they would stand for long.

If true, this situation becomes somewhat self-perpetuating

boie0025|11 years ago

Yes, I half expect to see something like:

  //Not sure what this line of code does, but if you 
  //delete it, you'll break the whole application 
in a bill one day.

titanomachy|11 years ago

Nice analogy. Legislature writes the source code of the law and the judiciary tries their damnedest to compile it into an executable program, rejecting the parts that they can't make sense of.