In general, while I think more things like Hacker News are a good thing, Product Hunt feels elitist to me.
The people who are already in the know and well connected can get lots of publicity, and those who are more independent or just starting out either can't post or don't get recognized.
I've also had multiple friends (who are much better connected in SF) create big roll-out plans where they get all their friends to quickly up vote them. While it's not technically a problem, it takes away the real test of "is the idea worth voting for" and turns it into more of a popularity contest.
Just my 2 cents. Maybe others have had great experiences (and certainly some of the "products" posted are cool), but I'm skeptical of Product Hunt in general...
My suggestion is to stick with truly democratic places to share your new things (if you want more unbiased feedback), and submit press/news directly to places -- they want good stories and interesting ideas/products to share with their readers if what you have is a genuine contribution.
Not sure what you mean by saying PH is elitist..
I believe that the "hose who are more independent or just starting out" can also get noticed and someone can see their product and submit it to Product Hunt as well.
It is all about the product quality in my opinion.
Anyway there are lots of other stories of Product Hunt success.
What would be the "democratic places to share your new things" you mentioned?
[+] [-] akumpf|11 years ago|reply
The people who are already in the know and well connected can get lots of publicity, and those who are more independent or just starting out either can't post or don't get recognized.
I've also had multiple friends (who are much better connected in SF) create big roll-out plans where they get all their friends to quickly up vote them. While it's not technically a problem, it takes away the real test of "is the idea worth voting for" and turns it into more of a popularity contest.
Just my 2 cents. Maybe others have had great experiences (and certainly some of the "products" posted are cool), but I'm skeptical of Product Hunt in general...
My suggestion is to stick with truly democratic places to share your new things (if you want more unbiased feedback), and submit press/news directly to places -- they want good stories and interesting ideas/products to share with their readers if what you have is a genuine contribution.
Good luck!
[+] [-] AKAI2|11 years ago|reply
What would be the "democratic places to share your new things" you mentioned?
[+] [-] Seth_R|11 years ago|reply
[+] [-] Allan332|11 years ago|reply
I do not think there's one specific time for submitting a product....