top | item 993181

(no title)

idebug | 16 years ago

using the same logic, couldn't they also take paper manufacturers to court, because someone wrote or drew something offensive on a piece of paper once upon a time? i don't understand the reasoning behind this.

discuss

order

nandemo|16 years ago

If you buy a notepad, the paper manufacturer doesn't own it anymore and has no control over it.

Google cannot claim it doesn't have control over its own servers.

A more apt brick-and-mortars analogy would be a theater that would let anyone use its projector, as long as ads chosen by the theater are displayed alongside. Surely in most countries the theater would be liable for showing illegal movies, no matter what they'd written in their disclaimers.

JacobAldridge|16 years ago

Only if the paper manufacturer then went and published the offensive words / drawings as well.

dkersten|16 years ago

Newspapers have often done this.