alcolade's comments

alcolade | 5 years ago | on: Git filtering mechanism isn't intended to be used the way Git LFS has used it

Can you suggest where those artifacts should be stored?

I often have projects that require third party libraries, and perhaps I change or upgrade the version of the library I use during the history of my project. I would like to have everything versioned together so if I check out a certain commit, I know that everything will work.

The downside of this is that my git repo will get bloated over time if I keep changing large dlls. I've sometimes made submodules to mitigate this problem. Git lfs also seemed like a good solution, but your comment makes me feel like I'm doing something bad here...

alcolade | 5 years ago | on: Who Is Alexander Grothendieck? (2008) [pdf]

You need to also count "points at infinity" in the "projective" plane. So the "projectivized" equations are actually X^2 + Y^2 = 1Z, and X^2 + Y^2 = 4Z. The intuition is similar to how 2 parallel lines will meet at the horizion (infinity).

alcolade | 7 years ago | on: What Is a Manifold?

I was thinking of the Riemann curvature tensor which is just some measure of curvature at each point. If the bug were at some point of S^2 he would notice the curvature.

Of course, this is assuming S^2 is getting its geometry from a certain embedding into R^3 that comes to mind. You could define different Riemann curvature tensors over S^2 that may have zero curvature in certain places, like squishing a balloon against a flat table for example.

I guess my point was that topology and curvature are different things (like you pointed out with your comment about RP^2), and saying that "a sphere looks flat locally" is missing the point!

Also, it didn't occur to me that this notion of curvature doesn't make sense in 1d, i.e. for S^1 like you said.

alcolade | 7 years ago | on: What Is a Manifold?

If the bug were truly mathematical, he would notice the curvature of S^1 and S^2 without walking around (since curvature is defined at each point), but that is obviously very pedantic of me and shows why I wouldn't write an article nearly as interesting as this one.
page 1