revolvingcur's comments

revolvingcur | 16 years ago | on: Scientists mine YouTube to study effects of Salvia divinorum

I share some concerns with the commenters on the article. Having used salvia a few times, I can confirm that the way in which it is smoked has a drastic effect on the outcome. I can't imagine that the variables (method of combustion and inhalation, temperature, quantity) can be reasonably controlled for by observing home videos.

revolvingcur | 16 years ago | on: My First BillG Review

I can validate this. I was an intern in '06 and routinely spelunked the org chart. I recall seeing up to 11 or 12 layers from bottom to top. I was 8 or 9 from Ballmer myself, if you regard my mentor as my immediate superior.

revolvingcur | 16 years ago | on: Amazing 3d iPhone app

It's nothing like the Johnny Chung Lee videos, but it's about as compelling and well-executed as the technique allows. I was at least 99 cents-worth amused.

revolvingcur | 16 years ago | on: Windows 7: Bogus ERROR_FILE_CORRUPT error

No. The complaint is that the error code is inaccurate and indistinguishable from correctly reported corruption. Moreover, it has an unnecessary disk check as a side-effect. This is more than a slight annoyance.

revolvingcur | 16 years ago | on: Private Methods are a Code Smell

I feel that the connotation of "code smell" is a little stronger than what you state, but mostly I take umbrage to this statement:

"Moving these methods to collaborators and making them public creates opportunities for future reuse without reducing the clarity of the original code."

This is the crux of the argument. After all, if you aren't planning for reuse, there's very little motivation to create a collaborating class unless the main class really is getting excessively large. But if you're guessing at future refactorings, especially when dealing with the types of specialized methods being discussed, you're probably optimizing prematurely.

I do strongly agree that private methods often have unnecessary dependencies. But this is a different design issue.

revolvingcur | 17 years ago | on: Ask HN: Got rejected by YC 6-12 months ago? Where are you now?

My team was a YC reject in April '08. My partner and I split and we've each spun out a few ideas independently. I now work as a web programmer at a Windows shop and moonlight in a variety of areas.

The reason for choosing this route was the pressure to be cash-flow positive as an individual through whatever means necessary.

revolvingcur | 17 years ago | on: Serial Port Communication in C#

Before you criticize this article as simplistic or unnecessary (arguments about interest to this audience aside), consider that .NET 1.1 didn't have built-in serial port communication. Having spent many hours hacking serial comm in C#, I can say that this would have been a welcome resource, even given its brevity.

revolvingcur | 18 years ago | on: Windows Vista source code

"2. Windows users are generally less clueful, and therefore require more time-consuming hand-holding."

And you earnestly believe that forcing them to use BSD would make them somehow better able to grok computing?

revolvingcur | 18 years ago | on: The people behind OkCupid launch Crazy Blind Date

I absolutely love this idea and can't wait for it to expand. One lil' bug, though: when I finish the "add location" process, I get this message: "Fatal error: Call to undefined function drawError() in [...]date_wizard.php on line 655"

revolvingcur | 18 years ago | on: .NET framework source code to be released

This is actually tremendously useful despite the fact that it isn't Open Source. Being able to view method implementations in the debugger will be a boon to performance, and will definitely remove a lot of guesswork.
page 4