top | item 15072520

Ask HN: Did HN remove the barrier to upvoting posts older than 15 days?

3 points| edotrajan | 8 years ago | reply

2 comments

order
[+] edotrajan|8 years ago|reply
Previously, I wasn't able to upvote old posts of user, if I did upvote it'd redirect to add to my favorite posts. Now, the upvote button upvotes.

Did the change came recently ?

[+] dang|8 years ago|reply
Yup, last night. Upvotes after the time window has expired are now recorded, but they still don't alter the point total. From a user point of view the only effect should be that you'll see the upvote arrow disappear (i.e. the standard indication that you upvoted this item). We'll see how this works for a while. If there are unintended consequences we might revert it.

We did this because users seemed to dislike being told that voting on an item was closed. Before we added that message, the software used to just silently drop votes on old items and no one complained. It was an interesting case of giving more info leading to a worse experience.