top | item 25180031

Ask HN: What is to Reddit, as Reddit was to Digg?

26 points| justicejames | 5 years ago

What is to Reddit, as Reddit was to Digg?

24 comments

order
[+] nikivi|5 years ago|reply
Reason Digg faded was that Reddit decentralized moderation across subreddits. Although there are still some global rules set by Reddit (no drug sourcing is one I personally disagree with).

https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy is federated Reddit. It's also open source just lacks community. Some things are also already better like more performant front end. If I was to bet on something to overtake Reddit, it would probably be it.

[+] duskwuff|5 years ago|reply
> Reason Digg faded was that Reddit decentralized moderation across subreddits.

What ultimately killed Digg was the disastrous "Digg v4" redesign in 2010. Reddit's features helped it capture the fleeing users, but it was ultimately Digg's actions that triggered the mass migration, and Digg never really recovered.

[+] SubGenius|5 years ago|reply
I'm building Gurlic. Wouldn't want to call it the next reddit, though.

https://gurlic.com

[+] pyuser583|5 years ago|reply
Officially my new favorite website!
[+] ev1|5 years ago|reply
Please put links on the footer in the header too. Infinite scroll makes for unclickable footer links. :)
[+] jfoster|5 years ago|reply
Facebook Groups, unfortunately; much less interesting than Reddit, but touching a far greater % of the population.
[+] schappim|5 years ago|reply
Unfortunately you're right. Whenever I speak w/ non-tech folks in a niche, they're part of a Facebook group.
[+] mariusor|5 years ago|reply
It doesn't yet have the features that will make it a real competitor, but I'm working on something called https://littr.me

It is a decentralized link aggregator based on ActivityPub.

There are also a number of other projects using the same paradigm in various states of development. In my opinion, when these will come together and intercommunicate with one another then we can say they represent the competition.

[+] charcuterie|5 years ago|reply
Ruqqus[0]. Its Reddit with a focus on anti-censorship. It was launched in 2019, so the community is not quite mature yet.

As you can probably guess, it is a truly hateful place.

Practically speaking it is essentially (from my observation) a safe space for racism, homophobia, anti-Semitism, covid denial, dangerous conspiracy theories, misinformation, etc.

I hesitate to bring attention to the site at all because I don’t want the hate to proliferate, but I suppose it is better to know this exists rather than letting it incubate hate under the radar.

Edit: I also want to say I think anti-censorship is noble and Ruqqus, as a technology, is pretty well done. I think building a non-hateful community on Ruqqus would elevate it to be better than Reddit.

[0]: https://github.com/ruqqus/ruqqus

[+] raptorraver|5 years ago|reply
I was hopeful when I first heard of Ruqqus ("reddit without censorship!") but after a visit I just realized that it's too toxic place to visit without going mad. We humans make good ideas turn so so bad.
[+] catacombs|5 years ago|reply
> Its Reddit with a focus on anti-censorship.

"anti-censorship" is just a euphemism for a place where someone can say the N-word without being banned.

[+] icedchai|5 years ago|reply
Maybe Usenet can have a comeback.
[+] joecool1029|5 years ago|reply
It sorta has been since a few years now. However, moderated groups will always face the spam problem. Spammers only forgot about it for some years because ISP's rarely include access these days (and text groups had been fairly dead by that time).
[+] magnora7|5 years ago|reply
Try out https://saidit.net

It uses the old reddit open source code, and the administration is even based around the pyramid of debate, similar to hackernews.

[+] barney54|5 years ago|reply
Hacker News. Once upon a time, Digg was good for tech-related news. It became more popular and people switched to Reddit and now to HN. I’m here for the same reason I was on Digg years ago.
[+] karmakaze|5 years ago|reply
Things with subs (Usenet, Reddit) are not comparable to things without (Digg, HN). I don't know of a significantly growing successor to Reddit.
[+] 3np|5 years ago|reply
I don’t think there is one (yet?). Apart from already mentioned ones, there is also Urbit, which is different in its own ways.
[+] wow_why|5 years ago|reply

[deleted]

[+] meowster|5 years ago|reply
Coincidentally, yesterday, I wrote a comment about looking to see if Parler would be a good alternative:

"I click on the top alternative, Parler, and the root page redirects to some advertising page about the site.

Whereas if I go to the root page of reddit, I get content.

I think that's a huge turn off for alot of people.

Show interesting content, and let the product speak for itself.

If you go to Hacker News, you see content, you don't see a page explaining why Hacker News is great.

I just closed the Parler website rather than figure out what hoops I have to jump through to see content and what it's like."